Advanced Search
Search

ESTONIYA - IMO 5109019

Ship
2,47310
FavoriteComment
More
Full Screen
Exfir Data
Download Photo

Photo
details

Photographer:
Gordy [ View profile ]
Title:
Estoniya
Added:
Aug 28, 2013
Views:
2,473
Image Resolution:
1,513 x 959

Description:

ESTONIA
IMO 5109019
Russian

Photo Credits: The William T Barber Collection Vic Australia

Cheers and GB

Gordy

Vessel
particulars

Current name:
EKATERINA II
Vessel Type:
Passengers Ship
Gross tonnage:
5,330 tons
Summer DWT:
1,332 tons

AIS Position
of this ship

There is no AIS Position Data available for this ship!

Would you like to add AIS Coverage?

Add AIS Coverage

Photo
Categories

This ship exists in the following categories:

Cruise Ships and Liners built 1950-1960 - 29 photos

Photographers
of this ship

(21)

BRIAN FISHER

1 photos

TEDINGHAM

2 photos

Mikkel

1 photos

John Jones

1 photos

Yvon Perchoc

1 photos

Wilfried

1 photos

Tony Garner

2 photos

vebe

1 photos

index

1 photos

jotabe

1 photos

Gordy

3 photos

Gary Markham

1 photos

Gena Anfimov

2 photos

Sushkov Oleg

2 photos

COMMENT THIS PHOTO(10)

Newest First
person
Ships registered in Greece for expamle had their names spelt as per the Greek alphabet on their hulls yet their name boards displayed their names in English ? Is this not the case perhaps for easy ID ?

Edit
comment

person
I'm a firm believer that the title should reflect the name displayed on the ship, in this case ESTONIA. If we are to adopt a name translated from the Cyrillic then no doubt most Russian vessels on this site will have a different spelling to that displayed on the name board. I have looked back through a few of my old books (eg Soviet Merchant Ships by Ambrose Greenway) and in each case her name is spelt ESTONIA.

Edit
comment

person
Well - in the 1970-71 and 1973-74 editions of Lloyd's Registers her name is clearly ESTONIA
while in 1983-84 and 1994-95 her name is ESTONIYA.

Edit
comment

person
Clive, I have checked several old Lloyd's Registers ranging a quite long period, and each time her name is spelled as Estoniya. So that seems to be the name under which she has officially been registered. A bridge sign is just an indication and is not even mandatory for flags.

Edit
comment

person
Pieter the size of the can of worms isn't particularly relevant. All that I was doing (the same as Robert J Smith) was pointing out that on her name board is spelled ESTONIA. If the administrators of this site want to spell it ESTONIYA then they'll do so regardless of what I or others may think.

Edit
comment

person
Clive, the can of worms is much bigger than you think. If a name of a Russian ship starts "E" many times the real pronounciation is reflected in the transcript and E becomes YE, and then again not always and everywhere.

Edit
comment

person
Her name as per IHS database (Lloyd's Register) is "EstoniYa", so that is clear.
As for the practice to write ships' names in English even if the original name is pronounced/spelled differently, the jury is still out on that one. There are examples of both cases, but in this particular one I'd go with the official source. Hence, EstoniYa.

Cheers

Vlad

PS

I see a forum thread coming. ;)

Edit
comment

person
Forgive me Pieter whilst I don't doubt your knowledge of the Cyrillic alphabet but that is not the correct answer. The name board aft of her bridge clearly states ESTONIA. Therefore, in English that is her name.

Edit
comment

person
Possibly because the two last characters in cyrilic translate as I and YA (the reversed R is YA)

Edit
comment

person
Why have all the photos in this group been renamed ESTONIYA when clearly the name on the board is ESTONIA?

Edit
comment